It was an enigma to me actually while I was reading Atkinson's book. Crime fiction? Really?
But I laughed it off thinking it absurd. Surely Professor Dienst knows better.
Yet, little that I know, he did asked us the same question in class today? What does the crimes in this book mean? What purpose does it serve, really?
Enough of class material.
I was intrigued by the "feel" that I got from the book, that I decided to watch the BBC series. Since Case Histories is part of a series featuring Jackson Brodie as the main character, I had watched the first 2 episodes that corresponds to this book.
All along I was telling myself, " This is so gonna be Jodi Picoult-like."
I was right.
Both episodes hung loosely onto the book, changing tiny facts to the case which bothered me as stories like this depend on the small bits to push it through. The obvious stuff is still there, and Brodie was all you can ask for on screen. He had that appeal in himself that he acted more like a confidante rather than the normal private eye we usually encounter, making you feel that the cases were never meant to be solved in the first place.
Amelia and Julia fared better on screen compared to the book, but Laura was a little bit plain.
Lily Rose was Lily Rose. Theo wasn't that gigantic though.
Overall, I would not say it is a remarkable rendering of the novel, but worth to watch, nonetheless. Especially if you want to see how things flush out using graphics rather than an over-active imagination.
The part where Olivia's killer did the deed was funny or absurd, depending on your level of seriousness. It was dramatic and garish (at least it was for me). It serves the purpose of fleshing out the reasons behind the killing but I felt that the producer took too much liberty on that one.
Oh well. Brodie is Lucius and how can Lucius be so yummy.
Help me wrap that thought into my brain folds.
Showing posts with label Movie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Movie. Show all posts
Tuesday, April 8, 2014
Sunday, February 16, 2014
BOOK TO MOVIE ; TALENTED MR RIPLEY
Curiosity got the better of me.
Why on earth did Professor Dienst assign the second best when we could read the best?
Having to make do with the resources I have, I turned to the screen. Maybe that was dear Professor's intention anyways.
Although I said that Ripley's game (refer blogpost before) wasn't that noir, he was an interesting character enough to prompt me to understand his character more. Hence the movie.
Having not read Talented Mr. Ripley yet, I was in for a surprise. This was the base for our character! How did he get rich, who was Dickie Greenleaf, and who Tom Ripley was before he is who he is in Ripley's Game. It was beautiful watching the preview of the book while knowing that this is about another book entirely.
Putting both the movie Talented Mr. Ripley and the book Ripley's Game on the table, I suggest that we read the whole series (nicknamed Ripliad)!
1)Talented Mr Ripley
2) Ripley Under Ground
3) Ripley's Game
4) The Boy Who Followed Ripley
5) Ripley Under Water
Boy oh boy, looking at the last installment gives me shivers. (Watch the movie!)
And...that might be a good gift for my upcoming birthday,no?
Sunday, December 29, 2013
BOOK TO MOVIE ; MYSTIC RIVER
I was intrigued. Not too much because of the book, but for the intepretation of the psycho.
So I watched it. Quite a while ago. Right after reading the book. And it was quite spot on. The neighbourhood was something different (oh well I imagined a suburb-y feeling but got the Jersey dose) but it sticks to the facts of the book. And it was worth watching. Micro scrutiny of a community.
I have to watch many more book adaptations.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)